Mike’s Bible Reading Journal
April 1, 2026 — Days 79–80 of 365
The Shade the Bramble Cannot Give
Judges 6–9 — Israel longed for a king to shelter them. Abimelech offered shade. But a thornbush has no canopy — only fire.
The Texts
“Then the trees said to the bramble, ‘You come and reign over us.’ And the bramble said to the trees, ‘If in good faith you are anointing me king over you, then come and take refuge in my shade, but if not, let fire come out of the bramble and devour the cedars of Lebanon.’”
— Judges 9:14–15
“Thus God returned the evil of Abimelech, which he committed against his father in killing his seventy brothers. And God also made all the evil of the men of Shechem return on their heads, and upon them came the curse of Jotham the son of Jerubbaal.”
— Judges 9:56–57
The Observation
Chapters 6 and 7 tell the story of Gideon — called by God from hiding in a winepress, given sign after sign, and then used by God to defeat the Midianites with three hundred men and torches in clay jars. God’s power through unlikely means.
But the story keeps going. The people ask Gideon to rule over them — you and your son and your grandson (Judges 8:22). Gideon refuses. The LORD will rule over you, he says. And then he proceeds to act like a king anyway — many wives, a son named Abimelech (meaning “my father is king”), an ephod that becomes a snare, seventy sons. When he dies the people immediately return to the Baals.
His son Abimelech goes further. He goes to his mother’s relatives in Shechem, appeals to blood connection, gets seventy pieces of silver from the temple of Baal-Berith, hires worthless men with it, and murders his seventy brothers on one stone (Judges 9:5). The men of Shechem make him king. Three years later the city that crowned him is burned and its tower collapsed on the heads of those who took refuge in it. Abimelech himself dies when a woman drops a millstone on his head from the tower wall.
The narrator steps back: Thus God returned the evil of Abimelech on his head, and made all the evil of the men of Shechem return on them, and upon them came the curse of Jotham (Judges 9:56–57).
What is this doing in the book? And what does it have to say about a people who keep looking for someone to shelter them?
What Came Out of Studying It
Abimelech is not a judge. The formula that structures every other judge story — Israel did evil, God gave them into the hand of an oppressor, Israel cried out, God raised up a deliverer — is absent here. God does not raise up Abimelech. Abimelech raises up himself. He is not a deliverer. He is the oppressor. And uniquely in Judges, the oppressor comes from inside Israel — from the family of the previous judge, funded by a Canaanite temple, ruling by Canaanite methods.
The corruption that Gideon partially resisted his son embodies completely. The boundary between Israel and Canaan that covenant faithfulness was supposed to maintain has dissolved from within.
Jotham’s parable. Before he flees for his life, Jotham — the one surviving brother — stands on Mount Gerizim and tells a parable (Judges 9:7–15). The mountain matters. This is the mountain of blessing from Deuteronomy 27. From the place where Israel once said amen to the blessings of the covenant, the last surviving son of Gideon pronounces a curse.
The trees go out to anoint a king over themselves. They ask the olive tree. The olive says — shall I leave my fatness by which God and men are honored and go to wave over the trees? They ask the fig. The fig says — shall I leave my sweetness and my good fruit? They ask the vine. The vine says — shall I leave my wine that cheers God and men? All three refuse. They are bearing fruit that genuinely serves. They will not leave that work for the position.
Only the bramble agrees. And the bramble’s terms are revealing: come and take refuge in my shade — and if not, let fire come out of the bramble and devour the cedars of Lebanon.
A thornbush has no shade. The offer is absurd. The protection it promises is the protection of something that can only destroy.
Jotham’s point is precise: if you have dealt in good faith with Gideon’s family, rejoice in Abimelech and let him rejoice in you. But if not — let fire come out from Abimelech and devour the men of Shechem. Let fire come out from the men of Shechem and devour Abimelech. Which is exactly what happened.
God returning evil. The narrator’s summary in Judges 9:56–57 is theologically careful. God returned the evil of Abimelech. God made the evil of Shechem return on them. He did not send new judgment from outside. He removed the restraint that keeps evil from consuming those who practice it and let it run its course. The Shechemites funded murder with temple silver. That funding came back to them through the man they funded. Abimelech killed his brothers on a stone. He died by a stone dropped from a wall — a death so shameful he commanded his armor-bearer to finish him so no one could say a woman killed him. The evil returned in kind.
The bramble and the people who choose it. Jotham’s real point is about Shechem, not Abimelech. The olive and the fig and the vine did not disappear. They were available. The bramble fills a vacuum created when those with genuine capacity to serve decline the position — and it rises when a people are desperate enough, or tribal enough, or afraid enough, to take whatever offers shade and calls them bone and flesh.
Abimelech’s pitch to the Shechemites was simple: remember I am your bone and your flesh (Judges 9:2). The appeal was to blood connection and shared identity, not to character or wisdom or capacity to lead. And it worked. The people chose the bramble because the bramble spoke their language. He told them their enemies were his enemies and their belonging was secured in him. And then the fire came.
The pattern recurs in every generation. A people who want to be told that their enemies are the real problem will find someone to tell them that. A people who prefer the promise of shelter to the slower, less dramatic fruit of genuine service will choose the bramble and discover too late that it has no canopy. Jotham’s parable does not need updating. It describes the same dynamic whenever it appears — ancient Shechem, medieval Christendom, modern democracies.
The harder question the parable asks is what kind of people produce bramble leaders. The culture that wants a bramble gets one. And once in power the bramble accelerates exactly the conditions that called it forth.
What This Means for Me
Running underneath all of this is a longing that is real and right even when it reaches for the wrong thing. The people who asked Gideon to rule over them were not simply power-hungry or naive. They were tired. They had been through the Midianite oppression. They had watched God deliver them through an unlikely man with clay jars and torches. And they wanted that to continue. They wanted someone to be responsible for their safety, their enemies, their future. They wanted a king.
That longing is not wrong. It is the longing Judges has been building toward — the longing for a true king, one who actually has shade to offer, whose protection is real because his roots go deep enough to support a real canopy. Every bramble that rises in Judges shows by negative example what the true king will not be. Abimelech kills his brothers to secure his position. The true king lays down his life for his brothers. Abimelech offers shade he cannot provide. The true king says come to me all who are weary and I will give you rest — and means it, because he is the vine, the true vine, with branches wide enough to shelter what he promises to shelter.
Jack Miller used to say that we are far worse than we knew but God’s grace is far greater than we imagined. The story of Abimelech and Shechem is the far worse side. A judge’s son becomes a Canaanite king. A city that should have known better chooses a bramble and is consumed by it. The descent in Judges presses the diagnosis deeper with each cycle until the question becomes unavoidable: what kind of deliverer do we actually need? One who will not die. One whose faithfulness does not depend on the people’s faithfulness to him. One whose rule does not extract loyalty through fear but produces it through love.
That is the king Judges is waiting for. And the fact that the longing keeps appearing — in Gideon’s story, in the people’s request, in Abimelech’s terrible parody of kingship — is evidence that the longing is real. We were made for a king. We keep looking for him in the wrong places.
The shade the bramble cannot give is real. It exists. It is available. But it comes from the one who said the kings of the Gentiles exercise lordship over them, but it shall not be so among you — whoever would be great among you must be your servant (Luke 22:25–26). And the whole of Judges is the long, painful argument that we cannot get there by our own choosing. We need the one who chooses us.
Key Scriptures
Judges 6:1–2 · Judges 8:22–23 · Judges 9:1–57 · Deuteronomy 27:11–13 · Genesis 2:23 · Matthew 11:28 · John 15:1–5 · Luke 22:25–26
Prayer
Father, I see my own heart in the people of Shechem. I go looking for shade in places that cannot provide it. Forgive me.
I pray for my country. We have been choosing brambles and calling it wisdom — valuing the promise of shade over the character of the one offering it, letting tribal loyalty do our thinking. Have mercy on a nation that keeps reaching for thornbushes and wondering why there is fire. Raise up leaders who actually bear fruit, and give us the humility to recognize them when they come.
And Father, I cannot read Jotham’s words — let fire come out of the bramble — without thinking of the fire falling right now. There is a war burning across the Middle East as I write this. Thousands are dead. Millions are displaced. American troops are in harm’s way while we sit here trying to find shade under a bramble tree. Families in Tehran, Beirut, and Tel Aviv are suffering in ways I cannot imagine from where I sit. Lord, have mercy. Bring this war to an end. Protect our soldiers. Comfort the grieving. Restrain the powerful. And forgive me for how easily I scroll past the suffering of others. Break my heart for what breaks yours.
Thank you that the true king has come — not to be served but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many. He is the shade we have been looking for. Help us to stop looking anywhere else. Amen.
Pray for the American troops deployed in the Middle East right now, and for the families on every side of this war who wanted nothing but safety and got fire instead.
Leave a Reply